Report on Confining GE Organisms Praised

Statement of CSPI Biotechnology Project Director Gregory Jaffe

January 20, 2004

The National Research Council’s report accurately describes the strengths and weaknesses of different confinement methods for genetically engineered (GE) organisms. Unfortunately, the report concludes that there are virtually no viable bioconfinement methods that could be adopted commercially without significant additional research and testing. The science for creating risky genetically engineered organisms clearly exists today, but methods for safely confining those organisms do not.

Until the science surrounding reliable confinement methods catches up with product development, only GE organisms determined to be safe without the need for strict confinement should be commercialized. Risky applications of genetic engineering—such as producing vaccines or other drugs in food crops—should not be allowed.

The federal government should immediately adopt the recommendations of the NRC report. Recommendations that would increase safety and consumer confidence include the report’s call for transparency and public participation in the regulatory process, a rigorous regulatory system with inspections and enforcement, extensive environmental monitoring, and consideration of the potential effects of a genetically engineered organism on other nations. Unfortunately, many of these same, sound, science-based principles have been rejected or ignored in the past. But until the regulatory system catches up with what the biotechnology industry wants to do, consumers and the environment will be at risk. – 30 –


Get Updates Via Email

Journalists can receive CSPI news releases via email.
Not a journalist?

Sign Up for Email Now



Subscribe Now

Subscribe Now »

Subscribe Today and Save!

In Recent Issues

Cover Story: 1 in 8: What You May Not Know About Breast Cancer

Special Feature: Soy Oh Soy: Is It Really Bad For You?

Brand-Name Rating: Pasta Sauce

Subscribe Now

Request permission to reuse content

The use of information from this site for commercial purposes is strictly prohibited without written permission from CSPI.